It was the beforehand 2000’s. Jam bands were a point. I visited undergrad in Granville, Ohio about 40 minutes from Columbus. I heard the O.A.R. song “Road Outside Columbus” at a college party a time or two or a hundred. We were not exactly subtle. With lyrics prefer, “My friends are here./A couple years I’ve spent, I found I have a second residence,” O.A.R. was pretty on the nose as well.

You are watching: Why oh why did i leave ohio

Print by Peter Nevins

Many kind of years later on, I tried to decipher the breathy lyricism of “Bloodbuzz, Ohio.” I’ve never been entirely clear what exactly this song is about, but I understand also it as a look at exactly how one navigates the location one is from and the perboy one is as an adult: “I was never married yet Ohio don’t remember me.”

Then, it was the Avett Brothers’ “Salina.” While this song is named for Salina, Kansas, the only lyrics I get stuck in my head are “Ohio I’m leaving/Ohio I’m gone.”

Over the years, I have involved realize exactly how many kind of songs are around Ohio, or at leastern describe a specific idea of Ohio. Ohio is residence. Ohio might be supplied in as a stand in for house bereason of the common vowel sounds alone, yet I have actually a more grand theory about songs around Ohio.

Ohio is home, but it is frequently a residence that has actually been left and can never before be returned to. Many of these songs are around a nostalgic look ago at a area that only exists in the creative thinking. The principle of residence gives a sentimental connection to Ohio however additionally casts it as a room that cannot be went back to. The person in the song misses Ohio and also bemoans that he or she can no longer go there—periodically literally however always metaphorically. The narrator might return to Ohio but cannot recapture the lost youth, the lost sobriety, or the shed love. Tbelow is a sadness to these songs. They are a lament.

Several of these songs are descendants of “Ohio” from the musical My Sister Eileen, which contains the refrain, “Why Oh, Why Oh, did I ever before leave Ohio,” The singer is upset about leaving Ohio and regrets the choices that have actually led to a life in New York. The lyrics, “Why Oh, Why Oh, did I ever leave Ohio?/Why did I wander to uncover what lies yonder?” and “Maybe I much better go home” are a cry around the choice to leave the safe boundaries of Ohio and try to have a different life in New York City.


However before, while the singer is longing for the simplicity of her previous life, she is likewise cementing her future of never before returning to Ohio. Ohio becomes a website of nostalgia that is disassociated from the present time of the song. The narrator feels the pull of Ohio, however the gulf is also wide to bridge.

“Ohio” is a song about sadness and also that heritage is lugged with the songs that derive from it. Versions of the “why oh” line have actually been used in songs from the Black Keys (“Whoa, oo-Whoa/Oo-Whoa, oo-Whoa/Oo-whoa hi-oh/Hi-oh”) to Gillian Welch (“Oh me oh my oh, look at Miss Ohio”). This song cemented a perception of Ohio that sticks through us this particular day. In all these songs, Ohio is a lost state.

Ohio is a area that the artists grapple with, but no one seems content with Ohio alone. Ohio is constantly vying for attention with locations that are more enticing. Many of the songs indicate kinship through Ohio, yet tbelow is always a feeling of Ohio as being a component of the past. Even the O.A.R. song, wbelow the narrator is even more serenely present in the space of Ohio, includes the finality of the past tense. The singer shows, “There’s a road outside Columbus, Ohio/Feels prefer I drove alengthy for years.” The narrator is not driving; he already “drove.” The perprevious could still be in his last years of college here—the members of O.A.R. checked out Ohio State—yet the tone is already nostalgic. For instance, in the lines quoted above, “A couple years I’ve spent,/I discovered I have a second home” the singer is content in his relationship to “home,” however tright here is not the feeling that Columbus will continue to be his home. It was his second house, yet what will be his following one?

Or take Kid Cudi’s “Cleveland is the Reaboy.” While affirming Cudi’s partnership to Ohio, it’s not specifically exuberant. The assonance of “Cleveland” and “reason” functions well through the declarative nature of the song, however the underlying message is that while Cleveland is responsible for shaping Kid Cudi, it shaped him simply sufficient to enable him to relocate on. Cudi raps, “I’m from a location wright here old school’s are common/Gotta explain eextremely time I’m rhymin’.” Cleveland also is foundational, yet it is additionally old institution. It forms you, yet it doesn’t understand you. And then you leave.


The gulf between what was happening in Ohio and also what you find about yourself as soon as you leave is portrayed in Tracy Chapman’s “Going Back.” This is among the darkest and also leastern nostalgic songs around Ohio, however it still grapples with the potential or absence of potential for reconciliation between the existing and also the previous. The singer can imagine every one of the past—“A yard for parked cars left to rot and forget/For chained-up mad dogs for garbage to sit”—however has no desire to revisit the place. However, even if Chapmale is not “going earlier,” Ohio reverbeprices via her current people. Ohio is “through me through me always.”

For some, the look back at Ohio is enjoyable. For others, prefer Chapmale, it is a bleaker image. Regardless, though, of the level of discomfort with the place, no one seems to shake Ohio. Ohio is imbedded in one’s identity. Even if it is a location the singer does not want to return to, it is still home—a house that requirements to be contended via.

This metaphorical space of home gives a sentipsychological link to Ohio while casting it as a area of the past in our imaginations. Ohio becomes a area that is not as modern and also up-to-day as many kind of various other components of the country. And this matters bereason well-known narratives around places assist cement our concepts of what we mean from and of those locations. People from the Midwest are laborious yet not progressive. The Midwest is stuck in the 90s. Etc. Some of concepts that feed these conversations are on the surface—“flyover states” for example—but our narratives of place often run deeper and are less apparent than we imagine. Songs around Ohio feed these unmindful stereoforms of the Midwest.

The perceptions of the Midwest are not just annoying to many who live and occupational in the region. They are a trouble bereason of just how restricted are the stories they carry out. After the recent presidential election, many type of media outlets have actually sought to “figure out” the area. The people that the national media outallows seem to discover over and over aacquire look quite homogenous. Many type of an short article has actually been written about the plight of the “white working class guy.” While these narratives are not false, they are also not representative of the entire region. I’m not saying that we should disregard the commercial history of the region or that human being are not struggling ideal now in traditionally functioning course jobs. Rather, we must expand our narratives to paint a much more finish photo of what Ohio, and also by extension the Midwest, looks prefer.

See more: Why Was It Necessary For Ford To Have A Prelaunch Campaign? Why Was The Ford Pre Launch Campaign Necessary

When you go to a area seeking a narrative, it is even more than likely that you will uncover that narrative. Our social perceptions of place feed and reinforce these concepts. Why aren’t stories of Ohio around the engineer at Case Western? Or the restaurateurs in Columbus? Where are the home wellness treatment workers? The farmers? The botanists? The park rangers? I’m asking us to obtain past the refrains of Ohio—also if the why oh, why oh, gets stuck in your head. We should press ourselves to uncover complicated stories in the area. And we have to listen to the people who spend their time there. We all deserve to our very own story, and we need to be seeking every one of the stories of the Midwest—not just the ones that fit our preconceived views.