Okay, so I read a bit of the manga, and I understand a great amount of spoilers. But why are many of the titan-shifters trying to destroy humanity? Eren and Ymir are good, right? Why execute some titan-shifters desire to ruin mankind, and what are Annie"s, the Colossal Titan"s, and also the Armored Titan"s backstories and motives?



Since there isn"t much revealed in the manga, this answer is going to be a speculative one.

You are watching: Why did reiner and bertholdt attack the wall

It"s known that the imperial family has been trying to wipe out the titans. They prepare someone to become the "Carrier" of the Coordinate, however each time a brand-new titan gets the power, they accede to the needs of the first king, that is to permit the titans to conquer humale, i.e. Titan dominance.

The major motive of the Titan Shifters is to recoup the Coordinate, unwell-known to the truth that just someone from the royal family members can usage it"s powers optimally.

This leads me to think that

The ape titan, is somehow regarded the royal household and desires to fulfill the first king"s wish.Or, he simply desires to convert all human beings to titans, therefore developing an just titan nation and also annihilating humanity.
Improve this answer
answered Jan 8 "16 at 13:40

Pratyush ManochaPratyush Manocha
2,00311 gold badge1414 silver badges3838 bronze badges
Add a comment |
I assumed I would certainly update this question with indevelopment leading approximately, and also including, Chapter 94 of the Attack on Titan manga. I realize that these inquiries are wide, and also the answer will be lengthy, however it’s worth having actually it all in a single area.

Warning, significant spoilers take place in the answer listed below. I have done my ideal to show wbelow the spoilers come from, however read at your own hazard.

I will certainly deal with the inquiries in this format so that you deserve to skip ahead if you need to:

Why are the titan shifters trying to destroy humanity? What are Ymir"s, Annie"s, Bertholdt"s, Reiner"s and Eren"s backstories and also motives?

First, it is super necessary to talk around the areas affiliated in this problem. From Chapter 93, web page 6, we see a geographic depiction of the world at this time:

A good deal of the story up until Chapter 86 had developed on the Island also of Paradis, within the three concentric wall surfaces - Maria, Rose, and also Sina - all situated in the region circled in red. Then, in Volume 21, Chapter 86, web page 163, we are visually made mindful of the mainland also which is the landmass referenced by the blue arrowhead. This landmass belongs to the Marleyan government. Finally, in Chapter 93, we are made of mindful of an additional existence, the area currently known as the Mid-East Allies which is suggested in pink. Tright here are various other regions that we have the right to watch from this map, yet they have actually not been discussed so far in the manga. Keep every one of this in mind as we move forward bereason the political occasions gain a tiny messy.


Now, let’s talk about the historical dispute between the regions specified over, especially the blue and red areas. Each side has their own perspective, and also we check out some fact in both. We’ll begin via the Marleyan perspective, because that’s what we’re presented through in Volume 21, Chapter 86, Pperiods 160-162 as soon as Grisha’s father is having a conversation via Grisha about the background of the problem in between Marley and Eldia. In this Marleyan perspective we find that

1,8two decades ago, the Eldians" ancestor Ymir Fritz made a contract through the earth adversary in exreadjust for the power of the titans. When Ymir passed away, her soul was split nine means into nine sepaprice titans. Using the power of the titans, Eldia dominated the nation of Marley, and started a phase defined by the Marleyan government as an ethnic cleansing that lasted 1,700 years. But, the previously overcame country of Marley had the ability to bring 7 of the 9 titans under their manage, therefore leading them to victory in the Great Titan War against Eldia. King Fritz escaped to the Island also of Paradis, constructed the three walls - Maria, Rose, and also Sina - and took refuge tbelow through some of his civilization. Unfortunately, not all Eldians escaped through King Fritz and also some were left behind; they lived in the internment zone for Eldians on the mainland.


In Chapter 87, web page 10, and likewise later in Chapter 89, our expertise of the Island also of Paradis is shattered once we uncover that it is

a penal nest implemented by the Marleyans. In fact, the mindmuch less titans are produced at the border of the Island of Paradis by the Marleyan government with injecting the titan serum right into the neck of Marleyan traitors (Eldians from the internment zone). This is done not only to punish the traitors by sentencing them to a life as a mindless titan however to keep the continuing to be Eldians trapped within their 3 concentric wall surfaces, utilizing the newly created mindmuch less titans as a resource of cheap armed forces labor that keeps the Eldians caged in.


In Chapter 87, pages 38-40, we view a deep-rooted social divide emerge during a conversation in between Grisha and also high-level Marleyan soldier when the soldier

Confirms a biological difference between the Marleys and the Eldians. That is to say, just the Eldians, or the topics of Ymir, are qualified of turning right into titans. It is with this conversation that we learn that the Marleyans safeguard themselves proactively by segregating and also oppressing the Eldians.


In Chapter 87, pages 38-40, we also check out that the original portrayal of historic events was not precise as soon as Grisha states

the original titan, Ymir Fritz, had actually imposed the titans to cultivate land also, create roads, construct bridges, etc. for the advantage of mankind.


Of course, we eventually view this is likewise not an exact historic representation of the creation of the titans, and also the events that developed thereafter. In Chapter 89, pperiods 28-31, the OWL tells Grisha that

that the Eldians were at fault also in the historic conflict. They provided the mindless titans as a method of warfare and not sindicate for the advantage of humankind. The OWL confirms the many kind of theories of the Eldian/Marleyan history and also dispute, yet in the end, the only amount of reality is in their reality.


Now that we’ve extended our historic problems, and also the players associated in the existing conflict, the only point left to talk about on the first question is the current problem. The reason some of the titan-shifters are “trying to ruin humanity” is because

The Marleyans require sources in the create of titan power (Chapter 92, Page 47) and fossil fuels found on the Island of Paradis, residence of the Eldians. The initially attempt to re-take Island Paradis was for natural resources, and also the second attempt to re-take Island also Paradis will be because the Marleyans nearly shed in fight to the Mid-East allies and also they require a present of pressure in the create of remarriage of all titans under the Marleyan banner. However, because the Marleyans deployed so many mindless titans as a way of originally securing the penal swarm (Island of Paradis) they currently need to resolve those mindmuch less titans prior to they deserve to secure the required resources and titan power. And, the only way to carry out that is to find the starting titan, so that they have a viable suggests of controlling the mindless titans. Hence, they sent their arsenal of titan-shifters into the penal swarm in an initiative to secure the founding titan and also the co-ordinate.

Okay, so we’ve obtained all that background story out of the means, let’s talk around the titan-shifters and also their backstories, allegiances, and also motives. Some will certainly be shorter than others and this is because there’s incredibly bit exceptional information around their backstory, motives, and also allegiances.

See more: Why Is A Differencing Disk Beneficial? Chapter 8 Flashcards

First, let"s talk a small around Ymir. Although her beginning story was fleburned out previously, I will recommendation Chapter 89 because it presents her backstory in chronological order which is a lot of beneficial for us to store things simple. In Chapter 89, pperiods 8-18, we find that

Ymir was once an Eldian beggar kid that lived on the mainland under Marley ascendancy. She was adopted by cultists, proclaiming that she was Ymir Fritz, and she was worshipped in key by this cult for quite some time. She went in addition to this role for the cultists in an effort to please them. Ultimately, however, the Marleyan government recorded on to the cult, which was performing illegal activities in the worship of Ymir Fritz, and Ymir took on their punishment for them. She was sent to the Island also of Paradis, sat alengthy the edge of the wall, injected via the titan serum, and thrvery own down into titan area to experience her punishment as a mindmuch less titan.


In Volume 12, Chapter 47, Page 18, it is revealed that

Ymir had actually invested 60 years as a mindless titan after she had been injected with the titan serum. It was revealed prior to this chapter, and later on evidenced in succeeding chapters that after some time, she hibernated under brush and also dirt till, in the year 845, Marcel Galliard, Reiner Braun, and Bertholdt Hoover were on their means to infiltprice Wall surface Maria and also they happened to cross paths through Ymir. She sprung out at Reiner, and also Marcel pumelted Reiner out of the method in an initiative to save him, however was eaten by Ymir in her mindless titan form. Marcel, the Jaws titan-shifter, therefore passed on his abilities to Ymir and she came to be the Jaws titan-shifter. However, she did not join pressures with Reiner and Bertholdt. Instead, she re-joined people where she met Krista (Historia Reiss) whom she came to be romantically interested in, and remained by her side until later events. In the Survey Corps battle to obtain Eren ago from Reiner, Ymir determined to let Krista go earlier to the Survey Corps and also parted via Krista to conserve Reiner and also Bertholdt. We don’t check out her aobtain in the story until a lot later.


Warning, major spoiler ahead. In Chapter 93, web page 97, our worst fears are confirmed when

Porco Galliard, the brvarious other of Marcel - the titan-shifter Ymir had consumed - stated that he had actually not yet been able to watch his brother’s memories but was able to learn a lot about Ymir after he had consumed her, even going as much as insulting her.


Up till this point, it is evident that Ymir’s allegiance is to

Krista all the method until fatality. Although Ymir was an Eldian, she did not side with either the Eldians or the Marleyans.

Next, let’s talk about the Female Titan who is

Annie Leonheart. Annie is an Eldian and also was elevated in the Eldian internment zone on the mainland also populated by the Marleyan government. She endetailed in training and demonstrated great fighting abilities and also was schosen by the Marleyan government to receive the power of the Female titan. She was component of the operation in 845 to infiltrate Wall Maria via Reiner, Marcel, and also Bertholdt and they were all her comrades from training. When she successfully infiltrated Wall Maria, she joined the 104th Training Corps. Her allegiance is to the Marleyan federal government but with the help of the Attack Titan, she was captured by the Eldians on the Island of Paradis and we haven’t heard anything solid about her because.

That brings us to the Colossus Titan that is

Bertholdt Hoover. Not many backstory for him. He flourished up in the Eldian internment zone in Marley. He enprovided in the training routine to be schosen for a titan power and got the power of the Colossus Titan. Up until his fatality, his allegiance was to the Marleyan government.

Next up is the Armored Titan who as of Chapter 94 is

Reiner Braun, an Eldian increased in the internment zone within the nation of Marley. Reiner, prefer Annie, Marcel, and Bertholdt, trained to be schosen for a titan power and he was schosen to get the Armored Titan. The Marleyan government sent Reiner to infiltprice Wall surface Maria in 845. However before, after remaining undercover in the 104th Training Corps, he displayed some residual emotional effects that caused him to forget he was working for the Marleyan federal government and also he had actually to be reminded on a couple of occasions, by Bertholdt Hoover, of the true nature of his mission.

We check out some understanding on Reiner’s humankind in Chapter 93, page 37 when

After shedding Marcel in 845, and also being prevented by Zeke from conserving Annie from the Eldians on the Island of Paradis, and incapable of saving Bertholdt as soon as he was consumed by an additional mindmuch less titan (the next Colossus Titan), we check out that Reiner suffers from grief and also the loss of his friends when he photos them as he’s talking to a group of younger recruits.


This sets the stage for a various Reiner, and influences his actions and allegiances as we check out at the extremely end of Chapter 93, Page 47

Reiner has actually made a idea to a potential candiday for the Armored Titan that he come to be the Armored Titan to save his peer, Gabi, from a "dark fate" and also the recruit then reflects ago on the case in a confmaking use of manner, wanting to both save his frifinish and also complimentary the Eldia civilization


In Chapter 94, peras 22-27, we check out Reiner at a family members dinner. He is asked by members of his household around the “devils on Island also Paradis” and also without a 2nd believed, Reiner portrays the Eldians tright here, especially those in the 104th Training Corp as

a team of normal world, various than Reiner, Bertholdt, and also Annie, each via their very own strengths and flegislations that were seen in an completely positive light as he recalls the occasions. This perspective confoffers the family members, and the household immediately covers up after Reiner, illustrating everyone on the Island also of Paradis as monsters that constructed a realm off corpses. But his perspective of his enemies at the dinner table calls Reiner’s allegiance into question. That being said, his present allegiance is to the Marleyan federal government. His only factor for enlisting as an Eldian in the Marleyan armed forces was so that his mommy and also father, one a Marleyan and the various other an Eldian, could be together aobtain. But the partnership was forbidden, and also being an honorary Marleyan with selection for a titan power would enable his household to be together.


And Eren, well, we know his allegiance is to

The Survey Corps, and after the re-taking of the Island also, the Survey Corps & the kingdom under Historia Reiss. His mother was devoured by a mindmuch less titan in the very beginning of the story and ever since he"s been out for revenge. More freshly, his expertise with memories has actually altered his perspective a bit, yet it has actually yet to change his allegiance. We will certainly need to obtain further right into the story to check out if events readjust his loyalty to Historia Reiss and also the Survey Corps.


Alappropriate, to sum it all up the conflict happening in Attack on Titan is

Due to the existing feud in between the Marleyans and Eldians, establimelted 1,700 years ago. The first attempt to take the Island also of Paradis by the Marleyans was to secure the organic sources on the Island. The second attempt to take the Island of Paradis will certainly be for the unification of titan power under the Marleyan government.

The adhering to titan-shifters have actually these allegiances:

Ymir, allegiance to KristaAnnie Leonheart, allegiance to Marley, made to believe Eldians on the Island also were evilBertholdt Hoover, allegiance to Marley, made to think Eldians on the Island also were evilReiner Braun, allegiance to Marley, made to think Eldians on the Island were evil yet appears to be newly questioning his allegiance in Chapter 94Eren Yeager, allegiance to Island also of Paradis, or the Eldians under Historia Reiss and the Survey Corps

Please note: I will update this answer as points readjust.