The common saying two is agency, three"s a crowd is regularly associated through a romantic context:

Prov. A way of asking a 3rd perkid to leave bereason you desire to be alone with someone. (Often implies that you desire to be alone with the perkid because you are romantically interested in him or her.) - (McGraw-Hill Thesaurus of American Idioms)

but in an extra basic feeling it may refer to the (undesired) intricacy that might arise from the presence of more topics as said in the complying with extract from Quora.

According to Ngram the expression spcheck out from the late 1nine century.

You are watching: Two is company three is a crowd

Questions:

What is the origin of this saying?

Was it the product of some romantic writer of the 19th century or does it have a different origin?

Was it initially a BrE or AmE expression?


etymology phrase-consumption
Share
Improve this question
Follow
edited Apr 16 "16 at 12:14
asked Apr 16 "16 at 7:44
user66974user66974
1
Add a comment |

1 Answer 1


Active Oldest Votes
5

‘... 3 also many’ (1678)

One of the earliest versions of “2 is firm, 3 is a crowd” was taped in 1678 by John Ray, in his repertoire lutz-heilmann.info Proverbs, p.471

One"s also few, 3 also many

As such, presumably, ‘two’ was then considered idyllic.

The Oxford Thesaurus of Word Origins claims that the original proverb is from 1730s, and also cites an lutz-heilmann.info translation from The Spanish and lutz-heilmann.info Dictionary by J. Stevens, printed in 1726.

Prov. Compañía de tres no vale res; A agency consisting of 3 is worth nopoint. It is the Spanish opinion that say that to store a mystery three are as well many, and also to be merry they are also few.

John Collins gives this translation which resembles more very closely the lutz-heilmann.info proverb (1834)

“Three persons in firm are also many for any trick affair, and also two few for social enjoyment.”

‘... three is none’ (1840)

From The Facts upon File Thesaurus of Proverbs by Martin H. Manser (link), we learn the following:

The proverb was initially taped in the mid-1ninth century, in the develop “Two is company however 3 is none,” (W.C. Hazlitt, lutz-heilmann.info Proverbs <1869>) but the sentiment it expresses is of earlier beginning.

Variants of this proverb: two is company yet three is none; two"s a couple, but three"s a crowd, four"s too many, and fives"s not enabled.

Henry Downes Miles" Cock Turpin, printed in 1840, consists of the following adage

Their conversation had actually proceeded for this reason much, and Dennis showed up around to market his solutions in some other shape, when Esther showed up slowly proceeding in the direction of them.

“Two is excellent firm once three is none”

Five years later on, we have actually this detailed evaluation in The Usurer. A Tale of Marseilles. composed by Percy B. St. John.

Two is company—three is none:” so claims the adage; but, as is often the case, the adage is in error. Tbelow are occasions once absolutely nopoint have the right to be even more delightful than for 2 world, of course of various sexes, to discover themselves alone, and interadjust all those sweet vows and soft nothings which make up the sum-full of a declaration and an acceptance. But still, 3 is often a much better number for enjoyment much than two. Even a pair of levers are more at their ease—particularly if the one that is primarily considered de trop is a talkative and companionable perboy

‘... three is trumpery’ (1866)

Yet an additional variant showed up in the late 1ninth century containing the term, trumpery, i.e., somepoint showy but worthmuch less.

An old rhyme Molly had actually heard -Betty usage would certainly save running in her head and also making her uneasy-— “Two is agency, Three is trumpery.”

Wives and also daughters, an Every-Day Story By Elizabeth Gaskell

‘... three"s a crowd’ (1870)

As for the more modern version containing the term “three"s a crowd” it appears to be Amerihave the right to. The earliest circumstances I uncovered is from Delaware Gazette. December 02, 1870, the short article is titled Miss Althea"s Rubbers

I had actually my reward when Stalso lifted me dvery own at our gate, and she sassist : "You"re your mother"s own gal ! You hain"t never before let me feel that two"s a company and three"s a crowd !" Steven had actually walked up the long path via me to bring my shawl, and also can have actually said just a word then—a woguy have the right to live lengthy on only a word, if it be loving enough—yet he almost threw the shawl throughout my arm, and also ran dvery own the route as if he were glad to be well rid of me.

As I "piled Ossa on Pelion" in my thoughts against the opportunity of his loving me as I wanted to be loved, the forenoon wore away, and also the apples were sorted.

See more: Which Of The Following Is True Of Moderators? Chapter 8 Psych 1B Flashcards

‘... 3 are a crowd’ (1872)

Courtesy of
Sven Yargs are the complying with two excerpts: “One of My Bygones,” in the Wichita City Eagle (November 21, 1872). It"s likewise worth discussing that the saying includes the plural verb:

“My dear turtle-doves.” she shelp at last, laying one hand also on mine and also looking tough at my frifinish. “I see just how it is through you. You have actually got to the suggest wbelow ‘two are a firm and 3 are a crowd.’”

And from a things titled "Proverbs" in the Juniata Sentinel and also Republican January 21, 1874. Here the verb is singular and also in the basic previous.

Now go and also ask a couple of doting lovers if they believe in that sort of thing <"the even more the merrier">. They would certainly undoubtedly think that two was firm, and also three was a crowd. One thing is particular it is difficult, incredibly hard to crowd that idea right into the heads of some that is or that wregarding be mother-in-laws