We understand that the perchild asked is able to carry out it.We don"t recognize if the person asked is able to perform it.
*

*

As waiwai993 answered, Can/May/Will have actually various definitions. However before asking someone if they can aid you usually indicates that you would choose their help, and also it gives the perchild an possibility to decline without being rude. Maybe they are able to aid in theory, yet can"t right now bereason they are also busy. In that situation they have the right to say that they can"t aid. If they ssuggest do not want to help they can simply decrease without a reason. So I would constantly use "Can you aid me via this" or "Could you assist me through this" unless I essential a much more specific case (such as I KNOW that they CAN, yet I am forcing to answer whether they WILL or not, or I understand that they are ABLE, however possibly their mommy will not let them*).

You are watching: Can you help me with this

* Note: I think it"s exceptionally inexplicable to usage "May you assist me" and also would certainly more than likely never say that under any circumstances, unless I was trying to be ironic.


Share
Improve this answer
Follow
answered Nov 11 "10 at 14:20
*

Mr. Shiny and also New 安宇Mr. Shiny and New 安宇
25.9k77 gold badges6767 silver badges128128 bronze badges
Add a comment |
20
I would actually offer a pair added options:

Under problem 1 (that you understand that the person is able to help, however you"re uncertain if they will):

Would you assist me via this?

Under problem 2 (you"re uncertain if that perkid is able to help):

Could you aid me with this?

These are similar in interpretation to will certainly and also have the right to respectively, but are a much more polite means of asking. I would particularly recommfinish these if you"re in more formal establishing, talking to strangers, and so on


Share
Improve this answer
Follow
answered Nov 11 "10 at 3:28
*

DustyDusty
18.4k44 gold badges6666 silver badges8787 bronze badges
2
Add a comment |
5
Can you assist me via this?

Technically, this asks if it is physically possible for the other perchild to aid. However, it is commonly used to expect "Will you assist me with this?"

May you assist me via this?

This is indistinguishable to "Are you permitted to aid me via this?"

Will you aid me through this?

This is the one you most likely want—it basically asks whether or not the various other perchild is going to aid.


Share
Improve this answer
Follow
answered Nov 11 "10 at 2:37
*

waiwai933waiwai933
13.9k99 gold badges6565 silver badges8787 bronze badges
9
| Sjust how 4 even more comments
0
As for me, I occasionally feel a bit shy talking to civilization, so I choose polite variants like:

Can you please help me with...?

or:

Can I ask you for help through...?

Or you deserve to just say:

I need your aid.

I do not have actually a lot experience in communication through lutz-heilmann.info-speakers, yet I think those variants can be supplied in different cases.


Share
Improve this answer
Follow
edited Sep 20 "11 at 21:24
Daniel
56k7272 gold badges250250 silver badges372372 bronze badges
answered Nov 12 "10 at 15:04
ElkomieElkomie
15311 gold badge11 silver badge66 bronze badges
Add a comment |
-1
May suggests that you are asking for permission. Can suggests that you are questioning somebody"s capacity. Will indicates that you are seeking a response around the future.

– Can you lift this? – May we go to the mall? – Will you contact me?


Share
Improve this answer
Follow
edited Nov 23 "12 at 20:30
coleopterist
30.2k2727 gold badges109109 silver badges194194 bronze badges
answered Nov 23 "12 at 20:08
Savannah LaurenSavannah Lauren
1
1
Add a comment |
-3
Why not ask etymology for some help here?

Words can comes from Proto-Germanic kunnan

to be mentally able, to have learnt

Can is about ability, skills, understanding exactly how to perform points, whereas the word may originates from Proto-Germanic root mag-, infinitive maganan, from Proto-Indo-European magh-

to be able, have power

May is around power, the position a person is in to provide or refuse another perboy permission to execute something, states the Online Etymology dictionary.

Can I go to the bathroom?

– etymologically – is not really appropriate for asking permission as it suggests something prefer Do you think I understand how to go to the bathroom?, which might sound rude, even! On the various other hand,

May I go to the bathroom?

– etymologically again – suggests somepoint like Would your highness allow me to go to the bathroom? and also, in the classmuch less human being we live in (?) we are not really all set to your-highness anyone if we can protect against it! Well, little youngsters cannot really prevent it for a question of stature and standing, however, as soon as you have grvery own up, using may is felt as humiliating, as if you were kneeling in front of someone.

See more: why can't most stis be transmitted through casual contact with people or contaminated objects?

Could I go to the bathroom?

represents a middle ground between rudeness and also self-humiliation, which deserve to satisfy both the speaker and also the listener!

Using the modal auxiliary can in the conditional, "unrealising" the present, making it theoretical, dampens the shock. I am asking around objective conditions (do you think I understand how to) however using the conditional rather of the existing puts more focus on the listener, on their ability to assess the instance, which is a tacit acknowledgement of their authority.